Q&A · 2:29:22 Four Malta-class carriers entering service in the 1950s could postpone a new British carrier design until the 1980s or 1990s.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:30:10 A supersonic Harrier would more likely produce a substantially larger Invincible-type carrier than revive CVA-01 directly.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:30:36 Surcouf's useful gun range was constrained by hull stability and target sighting, so a larger caliber would leave the basic platform problem intact.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:31:43 The losses exposed obsolete armored cruisers, not the impossibility of a modern 15,000-to-18,000-ton successor.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:33:17 Britain could adopt the modified JDAM anti-ship concept if it met a requirement, using its own rapid-procurement machinery rather than copying an American program label.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:34:36 Making the powerful R-4360 available in 1939 is too late for aircraft already entering service, but it could improve American designs fielded from 1941 onward.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:35:55 A naval attaché worked through the ambassador and a naval reporting hierarchy rather than sending every assessment directly to the Chief of Naval Operations.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:36:23 Saratoga, Independence, Nagato, an LST, and a fifth representative ship form a preservation list balancing famous capital ships with missing ship types.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:40:47 A ten-inch gun approaches twelve-inch weight and handling without delivering a battleship shell, while losing the faster fire of a 9.2-inch weapon.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:41:48 Type 64 was an informal joke about pairing Type 42 destroyers with Type 22 frigates, not a secret ship class.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:45:49 A C-295- or Sherpa-sized STOL transport marks the plausible upper end, with wingspan and deck handling becoming decisive constraints.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:49:10 Reliable autoloaders could make eleven-inch German batteries formidable, but overengineering would threaten combat reliability.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 2:52:31 A research answer should be repeatedly tested against broader evidence, including sources that challenge the initial view.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 2:59:10 The lighter aerial weapon protected aircraft range and survived water entry more easily, while ships and submarines could carry a heavier 21-inch torpedo.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:00:23 A surviving Yamato would let researchers cut into exceptionally thick armor and test how it was manufactured, bonded, and cooled.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:00:55 A locked rail carriage could move missile canisters from an internal magazine to VLS cells without the uncontrolled motion of a crane.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:03:33 A missile cruiser derived from the Alaska hull would be exceptionally large and might retain an 8-inch gun alongside its guided weapons.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:06:21 Britain ordered ships class by class, retained enormous yard capacity, and could pursue faster battlecruisers alongside fast battleships rather than stopping at four G3s and four N3s.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 3:09:18 Madden's papers envisioned dozens of carriers and several fleet-sized formations, warning against reading the announced G3 and N3 orders as Britain's maximum ambition.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:16:55 The Treasury controls spending but does not normally define another department's terminology; cross-government classification belongs to the Cabinet Office or prime ministerial level.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 3:17:49 The Geddes-era cuts depended on treaty-backed fleet reductions; without them, Britain would have to buy maritime security through construction.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:20:35 The Edinburgh subclass was intended to carry quadruple 6-inch turrets, and earlier success could have spread that higher volume of fire across more Town-class cruisers.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:21:17 A rapid ship-by-ship review produces about twelve probable losses, with several cases uncertain between Hs 293, Fritz X, and torpedo attack.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:24:08 A higher treaty ceiling could bring turreted 4.7-inch guns, more torpedoes, and a near-Daring combat fit before wartime electronics added weight.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:25:08 US carriers, airborne early warning, F-14s, submarines, and helicopter assault ships would suppress Argentine aviation before a direct landing on Stanley.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:28:39 A reliable automatic 6-inch weapon with Mark N5-level performance would remove much of the reason to continue developing the smaller 5.25-inch gun.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:29:27 The popular song arrived too late to inspire 1920s names, while religion, Irish partition, and weak Royal Navy precedent made a four-patron-saint class improbable.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:32:21 Larger 9.2-inch guns, American-style high-pressure steam machinery, and four inches of armor would transform the Royal Navy's cruiser force.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:32:48 Britain emerged from World War One with more maritime infrastructure than it possessed before World War Two or immediately after the next war.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:35:05 Italy's consistent long-term force development makes it the strongest candidate for the best postwar European naval recovery.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:35:35 Replacing British heavy cruisers with Des Moines-class ships adds automatic eight-inch guns and advanced radar, overwhelming Graf Spee and Japanese cruisers at range.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:38:16 An Invincible-sized ship could operate F-35Bs in principle, but deck and hangar space would keep the air group small.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 3:38:43 Two strike carriers plus three F-35-capable LHDs would give Britain enough overlapping hulls to absorb maintenance and operational surprises.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:42:50 The 1920s capital ships approached the limits of existing American docks and support capacity, requiring additional infrastructure as part of the program.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:43:56 The common 21-inch diameter concealed different warheads, propulsion choices, internal equipment, and test-derived construction decisions.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:44:39 A Yorktown-class ship best matches Ark Royal and could strengthen Mers-el-Kebir, Taranto, Atlantic interception, and Force H maintenance coverage.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:53:52 Economic relief would leave the French state's political distrust of its own armed forces unresolved.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:55:05 If the Royal Navy retained the Fleet Air Arm after 1919, its dependence on fighters for outer fleet defense would push British fighter development harder before 1939.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 3:56:07 Enterprise would return with stronger fighter-direction organization and a British model of continuous defense and smaller daytime strikes.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 3:57:28 Warship orders spread employment across shipyards, steel, timber, engineering, research, food, and local services more broadly than many other defense projects.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 4:00:52 The winning technical advantage often lies in affordable production, repair, and availability rather than the most impressive individual weapon.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 4:04:35 By the time Pacific demand required mass carrier orders, Britain would already be moving from Implacable toward Audacious or an equivalent improved design.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 4:05:24 The Admiralty knew what it wanted at ordering, then altered the design as new combat evidence changed the world the ships had to survive.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 4:06:16 Pensacola and Northampton resembled the Admiral Hipper problem because they looked well matched to a paper mission that did not correspond closely enough to combat reality.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Q&A · 4:06:38 The Royal Navy generally knew what cruisers were for; the harder question was which threat, endurance, and operating standard each design should meet.
From Bruships 138: Random Naval History Books from Me, Random Naval History Questions from You! · 4 Feb 2024
Chapter · 0:00 The opening explains why several naval, aviation, and transport figures could independently arrive at the merchant aircraft carrier concept.
From MAC Ships: Success having many Parents or simply Logical Conclusions? - Key Ship Series 8 Ship 2 · 2 Feb 2024
Chapter · 2:38 MAC ships retained civilian command and cargo work while a naval detachment operated a tiny Swordfish air group from the added flight deck.
From MAC Ships: Success having many Parents or simply Logical Conclusions? - Key Ship Series 8 Ship 2 · 2 Feb 2024
Notable Point · 5:31 The conversion paired awkward aircraft maintenance over perishable grain with the extraordinary endurance offered by tankers carrying aviation fuel.
From MAC Ships: Success having many Parents or simply Logical Conclusions? - Key Ship Series 8 Ship 2 · 2 Feb 2024