Q&A · 1:57:06 Churchill would be constrained by the eighteenth-century system, while Sandwich's administrative strengths would translate well to modern tools.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 1:59:14 A 30,000-35,000-ton design works better as an enlarged STOVL carrier than as a useful conventional carrier of its period.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:01:11 A counterfactual Japanese order lowers CVA-01's price enough for Britain to buy one alongside four existing Malta-class carriers.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:03:01 The Royal Navy still holds public open days, but ship and sailor availability constrains how often they can happen.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:03:53 Three carrier hulls can distribute aircraft between three locations, helping a navy meet worldwide commitments.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 2:05:06 Three Admiral conversions before the treaties could change Britain's carrier force and treaty bargaining, though the underlying design proposal remains incompletely documented.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:08:09 Turbo-electric drive sacrifices some efficiency for flexible power routing, shorter shafts, maintenance access, and battle damage resilience.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:16:33 Floating dry docks made repair capacity movable, resilient, and valuable enough to receive major convoy protection.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:21:05 Ancient galleys and sailing warships illustrate recurring differences between inexpensive presence vessels, useful middle sizes and large command platforms.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:23:15 Cruiser requirements came from trade-route maps, enemy geography, patrol areas, response forces, and maintenance allowances.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:25:03 An earlier supersonic STOVL aircraft would reshape the replacement path but would not eliminate the eventual need for an F-35B-like successor.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:26:58 Long production experience favoured the pom-pom, while adapting Bofors manufacture exposed differences in measurements, fitting and initial production scale.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:31:09 GCAP is not expected to be STOVL, while a French SCAF carrier aircraft would require major changes to British carriers and their operating arrangements.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 2:34:09 A replacement expected about a decade away leaves an immediate need to modernise Typhoon and plan for several fighter generations serving together.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 2:36:53 Long procurement lead times and existing contracts can keep work moving after the original military requirement has changed.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 2:38:16 Plans for Albion and Bulwark expose the tension between immediate British defence priorities and commitments to reinforce Norway.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:41:58 A hypothetical loss of Iowa prompts agreement on inspections and caution about later reactivation, but different answers on retirement timing.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:43:01 The N3-Yamato and G3-Iowa analogy conveys scale and ambition, but differences in speed and classification limit its precision.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:44:59 An early, credible leak would push Britain toward heavier King George V-class armament and could revive a 16-inch program.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:55:01 A Tiger could provide command space and dense gunfire against Argentine aircraft over San Carlos Water.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 2:56:08 Helicopters and V-22s reduce cost and logistics streams while serving ships beyond the carrier deck.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:00:02 USS United States supplies the starting comparison for an intentionally unconstrained postwar bomber carrier.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:01:29 Triple-digit cruiser fleets would let Britain and America overwhelm most naval problems with massed hulls and torpedoes.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:03:21 Force Z's speed would let it avoid a surface engagement until Allied air support could influence the pursuit.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:05:14 The United States would answer a Chinese large combatant with new construction or more carrier capacity, not another Iowa recommissioning.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:08:06 Britain would probably convert all three ships of one group rather than mix one Admiral conversion with the Courageous class.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:08:58 The proposed repairs differ over gun calibre but agree on reliable machinery, controlled topweight, and armament suited to destroyer work.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:13:46 Atlantic endurance could make German destroyers grow beyond their role, encouraging a different mix of cruisers and local torpedo boats.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:15:52 Parker was supposedly too ill for the Admiralty yet well enough to command the Mediterranean Fleet away from politicians.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:17:31 Pristine Nelson-class ships offer space for missiles, helicopters, and new propulsion, with disagreement over how much main armament to retain.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:22:24 Firing restrictions manage blast damage and repair costs, while urgent combat can justify angles avoided during peacetime training.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:26:04 A discussion of Harpoon separates shock damage behind armour from a conditional claim about penetration with a suitable warhead.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:26:46 Playful Primarch comparisons distinguish Eisenhower's logistical leadership and other personalities, then consider the analogy's medieval influences.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:31:54 The US Navy needs frigates for routine presence and larger combatants for escalation rather than another single universal ship.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:33:19 A crane-handled caisson needs several deliberate removal steps, while a powered gate is more convenient but can jam or fail to close.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:36:51 Adoption followed quickly where iron production was strong and ship size made additional structural support worthwhile.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:37:24 A caisson's apparent crane limit could be overcome by coordinating two cranes, although the lift became much harder to execute safely.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:38:55 Matching Queen Elizabeth-class speed with 16-inch guns would require much larger American hulls and alter treaty-era fleet competition.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:40:18 A caisson that becomes buoyant after pumping can be moved by tug, providing another method besides crane lifting.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:41:02 Earlier spending could accelerate American sea power and war with Spain, but a later budget collapse might damage the new industrial base.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:42:55 Modern global threats and the presence of superpowers limit comparisons between Britain's position and earlier great-power systems.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:46:41 An interpretation of Roman decline connects dependence on expansion with inadequate internal investment and failure to sustain the armed forces.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:47:21 A 1920s semiconductor could transform naval electronics, but engineers would first need tools, theory, sensors, and code able to exploit it.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:50:09 The preference for Welsh anthracite is conditional because Alberta's coal quality is unknown in this comparison.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Notable Point · 3:50:31 Introducing an advanced component first reverses the usual development path and leaves engineers to invent the tools and uses around it.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:51:50 Armstrong's ability to construct a funded 21-inch gun is accepted, while the finished weapon's performance remains an open question.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:52:55 Beresford's clashes with Percy Scott and other officers left him without the support needed to become First Sea Lord.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025
Q&A · 3:54:19 Uncrewed aircraft could take over carrier early warning, while the weight of useful tanker aircraft remains a harder obstacle for STOVL ships.
From Bruships 181: Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 2 Feb 2025