Q&A · 2:05:46-2:06:21

Could Beatty lose Lion even if Goeben was sunk?

Losing Lion remains possible despite an expected British victory, although Beatty's ability in individual ship tactics makes that outcome less likely.

Battlecruisers David Beatty Lion Class Battlecruisers SMS Goeben

Watch at this time Full video guide

Question

Could Beatty lose Lion even if the Royal Navy sank Goeben?

Short answer

Yes. A lucky German hit could cost Britain Lion, although that outcome is judged unlikely because individual ship tactics were one of Beatty's strengths.

Notes

A victory over Goeben could still cost Britain Lion. A lucky hit keeps that risk in the counterfactual, even when the British ship has better prospects. The expectation of success rests partly on Beatty's competence in individual ship command.