Q&A · 3:59:08-4:00:49

Gun caliber, pacific gestures, and battleship arms races

Real design tradeoffs sat alongside the political symbolism attached to fourteen- and sixteen-inch guns.

Question

How much did fear of starting an arms race influence the gun caliber Britain selected as its standard?

Short answer

Little during the immediate post-World War I qualitative race, but 1930s support for fourteen-inch guns became a political effort to appear less aggressive and fit balanced ships inside treaty limits.

Notes

Britain and the United States were already engaged in qualitative competition around 1918-1919, so fear of appearing to start it did not dominate early choices. In the 1930s, politicians could present fourteen-inch guns as more pacific and easier to balance within treaty displacement, although fewer sixteen-inch guns could meet the same weight constraint and the symbolism did not erase strategic rivalry.