Q&A · 1:47:37-1:48:28

Why some air-power advocates resist aircraft carriers

Carrier aviation challenges theories centered on ever-longer aircraft range and implies a separate naval aviation profession with different requirements.

Question

Why do many air-power advocates dislike aircraft carriers?

Short answer

Carriers compete with land-based range arguments and reveal that naval aviation requires a distinct service culture and set of capabilities.

Notes

Some air-power advocates preferred extending aircraft range and capability from land bases. An aircraft carrier answers the distance problem by bringing the airfield closer to the target. Carrier aviation also has sufficiently different requirements to support an argument for separate service organization. That implication could put it at odds with advocates of a unified air service, especially in the interwar period.