Q&A · 52:31-52:42

Active ASDIC displaced passive listening during the 1920s

The transition from passive hydrophones to active ASDIC depended on reliable equipment and trained crews, not merely the first appearance of the technology.

Question

When did active ASDIC supersede passive hydrophone detection?

Short answer

During the 1920s, especially as reliable fittings and trained crews became sufficiently widespread by the middle of the decade.

Notes

The transition came broadly during the 1920s as the Royal Navy gained confidence in active sound detection. ASDIC appeared around 1920, but useful numbers were not fitted and exercised until roughly 1924-25. Passive listening therefore gave way gradually. System reliability and operator familiarity had to mature before active detection became a fleet practice. Possessing a new device was only the beginning of building an operational capability.