Video
A Book or Two to Review (32): Total Germany
Study A Book or Two to Review (32): Total Germany, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 16 Sept 2021, with 11 time notes. Topics include Book Reviews, David Wragg, Escort Carriers.
Time notes
- 0:20A compact, well-illustrated route into the naval warNotable Point
David Wragg's Total Germany is presented as a deliberately concise, visually rich introduction rather than an exhaustive operational history.
- 2:19A Royal Navy-centred survey of the warChapter
The review outlines a compact history that follows the Royal Navy and Allied navies from the opening campaigns to the postwar balance of fleets.
- 4:05Why modern naval conclusions date quicklyNotable Point
A contemporary assessment of Type 45 upgrades, Type 83 plans, or carrier aviation can be overtaken quickly by new decisions and technology.
- 6:00The operational scale behind familiar battlesNotable Point
Midway, Taranto, Pearl Harbor, and Matapan were not isolated ship actions but immense operations sustained by fleets, support ships, and simultaneous commitments.
- 7:54CAM ships, MAC ships, and escort carriersChapter
The review distinguishes catapult ships with single-use fighters, merchant aircraft carriers, and commissioned escort carriers as different answers to convoy air cover.
- 9:37How MAC-ship conversion moved from idea to serviceChapter
MAC ships illustrate how an urgent convoy requirement still had to pass through design, risk, production, and organizational constraints before becoming operational.
- 11:17MAC squadrons and their Atlantic convoy recordChapter
The scale and results of MAC-ship aviation show how continuous Swordfish patrols protected Atlantic convoys even without a recorded successful attack on a U-boat.
- 12:32From Dutch MAC ships to Karel DoormanNotable Point
Dutch service aboard MAC ships became part of the institutional bridge to the Royal Netherlands Navy's postwar escort carrier Karel Doorman.
- 13:03The Admiralty work behind the MAC-ship shortcutNotable Point
The familiar story of James Lithgow's rough MAC-ship sketch obscures earlier carrier plans, internal Admiralty disagreement, and the detailed design work needed to make the idea viable.
- 14:26Reading an overview alongside specialist historyNotable Point
A concise naval history can be accurate at its chosen scale while still leaving room for specialist disagreement over design debates and institutional detail.
- 16:17A fast, usable introduction to the naval warChapter
The book earns a wholehearted recommendation as an enjoyable, rapid entry point for readers who want the whole war in view before pursuing its details.