Video

A Book or Two to Review (32): Total Germany

Study A Book or Two to Review (32): Total Germany, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 16 Sept 2021, with 11 time notes. Topics include Book Reviews, David Wragg, Escort Carriers.

Date
Runtime18:02
Guide points11 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:20
    A compact, well-illustrated route into the naval war

    David Wragg's Total Germany is presented as a deliberately concise, visually rich introduction rather than an exhaustive operational history.

    Notable Point
  2. 2:19
    A Royal Navy-centred survey of the war

    The review outlines a compact history that follows the Royal Navy and Allied navies from the opening campaigns to the postwar balance of fleets.

    Chapter
  3. 4:05
    Why modern naval conclusions date quickly

    A contemporary assessment of Type 45 upgrades, Type 83 plans, or carrier aviation can be overtaken quickly by new decisions and technology.

    Notable Point
  4. 6:00
    The operational scale behind familiar battles

    Midway, Taranto, Pearl Harbor, and Matapan were not isolated ship actions but immense operations sustained by fleets, support ships, and simultaneous commitments.

    Notable Point
  5. 7:54
    CAM ships, MAC ships, and escort carriers

    The review distinguishes catapult ships with single-use fighters, merchant aircraft carriers, and commissioned escort carriers as different answers to convoy air cover.

    Chapter
  6. 9:37
    How MAC-ship conversion moved from idea to service

    MAC ships illustrate how an urgent convoy requirement still had to pass through design, risk, production, and organizational constraints before becoming operational.

    Chapter
  7. 11:17
    MAC squadrons and their Atlantic convoy record

    The scale and results of MAC-ship aviation show how continuous Swordfish patrols protected Atlantic convoys even without a recorded successful attack on a U-boat.

    Chapter
  8. 12:32
    From Dutch MAC ships to Karel Doorman

    Dutch service aboard MAC ships became part of the institutional bridge to the Royal Netherlands Navy's postwar escort carrier Karel Doorman.

    Notable Point
  9. 13:03
    The Admiralty work behind the MAC-ship shortcut

    The familiar story of James Lithgow's rough MAC-ship sketch obscures earlier carrier plans, internal Admiralty disagreement, and the detailed design work needed to make the idea viable.

    Notable Point
  10. 14:26
    Reading an overview alongside specialist history

    A concise naval history can be accurate at its chosen scale while still leaving room for specialist disagreement over design debates and institutional detail.

    Notable Point
  11. 16:17
    A fast, usable introduction to the naval war

    The book earns a wholehearted recommendation as an enjoyable, rapid entry point for readers who want the whole war in view before pursuing its details.

    Chapter