Q&A · 3:48:44-3:51:09

Could a worldwide dominion federation remain together?

The imagined federation's durability depends on domestic self-government, while worldwide jurisdiction would constrain foreign support for rebellions.

Question

How long could the hypothetical global British Empire survive?

Short answer

No duration is given. Survival is made conditional on how it governs: oppressive rule would be unstable, while dominion autonomy and the absence of foreign sponsors change the causes and resources of rebellion.

Notes

The survival question is answered conditionally: oppressive rule would make the imagined world empire unstable, while local self-government would give its regions more control over domestic affairs. The proposed dominion structure reserves common trade and defence questions for a federal government. With every region inside the same state, the scenario also removes foreign governments that might supply a rebellion. German arms supplied to the Boers are used as the comparison: under the hypothetical world government, those suppliers would face sanctions and arrest. Rebellions are still possible in the discussion; the claim is that they would lack the same external support.