Q&A · 1:23:20-1:23:42

Why torpedo-battleship ideas survived Tsushima

A follow-up question explains why Russian and American designers could still consider torpedo-heavy battleships after Tsushima despite the poor firing opportunities of earlier fixed tubes.

Question

Why did Russian and American designers still consider torpedo-heavy battleships after Tsushima?

Short answer

Torpedo range was improving, and designers hoped that a sufficiently large salvo could cause the underwater damage needed to sink a capital ship.

Notes

The earlier discussion showed that short-ranged fixed tubes were badly matched to battleship gunnery ranges. The concept nevertheless survived because torpedo range was increasing. Designers could also imagine a large salvo opening many underwater holes and producing decisive flooding. A weak first generation of a weapon can remain attractive when engineers expect rapid technical improvement.