Was Fisher's Baltic project inevitably doomed?

Is it fair to call Fisher's Baltic project an inevitable disaster?

No. The concept could have worked if executed quickly and correctly, although Fisher's weakness in amphibious operations makes successful execution doubtful.

Failure was not inherent in the idea of a rapid Baltic operation. Timing, preparation, and correct execution could have made the plan viable. The reservation concerns John Fisher's record and judgment in amphibious operations rather than naval daring in general. A concept can be possible while the proposed organization remains poorly suited to deliver it. This conditional judgment stops short of treating the project as a doomed fantasy.