Merchant disguise long predates the World War I Q-ship. Royal Navy ships hunting privateers often altered their appearance to look like harmless trading vessels. The French commander bluffed at Pulo Aura later encountered the reverse trick when a Royal Navy squadron sailed like a disorderly merchant convoy. A 98-gun second-rate reached dangerously close range before the French recognized the trap. Together, the two episodes show merchants imitating warships and warships imitating merchants with the same visual cues.
Notable Point ยท 14:04-17:07
Warships repeatedly borrowed merchant identities
The merchant disguise in Master and Commander reflects a long naval practice rather than a World War I invention.