Q&A · 8:35-12:05

A 1930 war favors the Royal Navy's aviation lead

A 1930 outbreak finds carrier aviation immature outside Britain and Germany far short of its 1939 capabilities.

Question

How would the naval balance differ if a world war began in 1930?

Short answer

Britain would hold the strongest carrier position, while Germany and the other Axis powers would be much less prepared than in 1939.

Notes

The 1930 carrier balance favors Britain over the United States and Japan. Lexington and Saratoga are the principal American carriers, Japan lacks several later flight decks, and Britain holds the strongest numerical position. Germany has none of the surface fleet that made its 1939 operations possible, while Italy has not completed later reconstruction programs. Doctrine might change little. The material balance and the operations each navy can attempt would change enormously.