Could Villeneuve have stayed in port and waited for Nelson to retreat?
Short answerNelson was not going to retreat, while the impending arrival of Villeneuve's replacement gave him a personal reason to seek battle.
NotesVilleneuve's departure is explained through the approach of Rosily, who was coming south to replace him. Fighting offered a chance to recover his honour and reputation before losing command. The expectation that Nelson would simply withdraw to Gibraltar offered no dependable alternative.