Q&A · 2:01:38-2:05:25

If Veinticinco de Mayo stayed at sea in 1982

Remaining in the operational area would probably expose the Argentine carrier and its Skyhawks to HMS Splendid before the strike could develop.

Question

What if the Argentine Navy did not withdraw Veinticinco de Mayo during the Falklands War?

Short answer

HMS Splendid probably sinks her and removes the embarked Skyhawks from later operations, especially if the carrier begins launching its strike.

Notes

The discussion identifies HMS Splendid after initially confusing the submarine's name. Alex Clarke's recalled account has Splendid watching the carrier prepare a strike and ready to attack if the aircraft began launching. The exact orders and mix of torpedoes are qualified as his recollection. Veinticinco de Mayo's withdrawal removes the opportunity before the broader attack order arrives. If the carrier remained and was sunk, her embarked Skyhawks would also be lost and unavailable for later attacks. That conclusion concerns the aircraft aboard this ship, rather than every Argentine Skyhawk unit.