Chapter · 41:12-44:30

Uncertain wars and escalation below the shooting threshold

A modern comparison shows why planners cannot choose the time, place, or threshold of conflict and must account for coercion by nominally civilian vessels and hidden undersea activity.

Notes

Cold War force planning gives way here to the difficulty of predicting where, when, and at what level a conflict will begin. Both sides act on imperfect assumptions about what an opponent will tolerate, making escalation a reciprocal calculation rather than a controlled schedule. Clashes on the India-China border illustrate how rivals may deliberately fight with limited weapons to stay below a feared threshold. At sea, trawlers and other nominally civilian vessels can harass warships while undersea activity remains even harder to observe or attribute. A navy must prepare for ambiguous coercion as well as declared war, because strategy cannot assume the enemy will select a convenient form of conflict.