Q&A · 32:53-33:56

Why treaty cruisers used four twin turrets instead of three triples

A question about the London class opens a comparison between a nine-gun triple-turret battery and the survivability of four twin turrets under the 10,000-ton limit.

Question

Why did the London-class cruiser use four twin 8-inch turrets rather than three triple turrets?

Short answer

Keeping within the treaty limit, designers judged four twin turrets more survivable than three triples, even though the triple layout would have added a ninth gun.

Notes

The answer treats the layout as a trade between the extra barrel offered by three triple turrets and the resilience gained by spreading eight guns across four mounts. Under the 10,000-ton treaty limit, the designers preferred the latter arrangement. A four-turret ship could retain more of its battery after losing a mount, even though it began with one fewer gun. A proposed late-1930s Royal Navy cruiser with twelve 9.2-inch guns in four triple turrets shows how a larger design could support a much heavier battery.