Q&A · 13:41-15:29

If Turtle had succeeded

A successful Turtle attack could have started an early contest to develop increasingly capable submarines.

Question

What if Turtle's attack had succeeded during the American Revolutionary War?

Short answer

It could have accelerated competing submarine programs and begun a much earlier underwater arms race.

Notes

The counterfactual begins with an American effort to scale the successful one-man Turtle into two-person and then larger craft. Britain would respond with its own designs, producing an Anglo-American underwater arms race generations before the historical submarine competition. The unusual rounded hull might persist for a time before builders adopted the easier cylindrical form. Because a sphere can withstand deep-water pressure well, the experiment could still influence diving performance even if it eventually proved awkward to steer. An eighteenth-century operational success would therefore change both the pace and the physical starting point of submarine development before the First World War.