Q&A ยท 3:28:58-3:32:50

Why favor the larger Town class over the Crown Colonies?

Larger size and better balance underpin the preference for Towns, while the Crown Colonies' treaty compromise places them between older cruiser categories.

Question

Why are the Town-class cruisers your favorite compared with the Crown Colonies?

Short answer

Their larger size and better balance explain the preference, while the Crown Colonies had to appear compatible with an 8,000-ton limit.

Notes

The preference for the Town class rests on their larger size and better balance. Both classes came under Henderson, so a preference for his work does not distinguish them. Crown Colonies remained good ships, but had to look plausibly smaller than the nominally 10,000-ton Towns to support their own 8,000-ton claim. In a comparison with older cruiser categories, the Towns resemble first-class protected cruisers. Crown Colonies sit between first and second class, moving closer to Leanders after losing the fourth turret and dropping to nine guns.