Q&A · 1:54:05-1:55:06

Why harbour torpedo nets could not solve the Dardanelles mine threat

Harbour torpedo nets were unsuitable for underway mine protection because of water resistance and the mines' larger charges.

Question

Could the pre-dreadnoughts' existing torpedo nets have protected them from Dardanelles mines?

Short answer

No. The nets worked while stationary, whereas movement and larger mine charges required different cables and supporting structures.

Notes

Pre-dreadnoughts could deploy torpedo nets while stationary in harbour. Underway, water resistance would push the nets out of their intended position. The mines being discussed also carried larger explosive charges than contemporary torpedoes. Protection for an advancing ship therefore needed different cables and metal framing suited to movement through the water.