Q&A ยท 3:13:06-3:13:37

Titan and the burden of rejecting engineering precedent

Established pressure-hull materials deserve investigation before a designer discards them as mere convention.

Question

What engineering lesson should be taken from the Titan submersible disaster?

Short answer

Investigate why established designers rejected a material or method before assuming that convention reflects a lack of imagination.

Notes

Earlier marine engineers may have had sound reasons for rejecting a material or method. An unconventional design therefore needs more justification than confidence that its designer is cleverer than previous generations. Established material choices are a reason to investigate the engineering constraints before departing from them.