Q&A · 1:25:14-1:27:58

A 24-gun Tilman battleship in place of Bismarck

A super-battleship counterfactual demonstrates how the Royal Navy's depth could offset an individually superior German ship.

Question

How would the Bismarck sortie change if Germany fielded a 30-knot battleship with twenty-four 16-inch guns?

Short answer

Hood and Prince of Wales would withdraw toward reinforcements while British carriers, battleships, and cruisers concentrated to damage and overwhelm the much larger raider.

Notes

The British would avoid a fair duel and retreat toward King George V, Victorious, Rodney, and potentially Renown and Ark Royal while mounting repeated air attacks. Germany could not match Britain's intelligence, reinforcement network, and ability to throw several adequate forces against one exceptional hull.