Q&A · 3:51:02-3:54:47

Task Force 34 against the Japanese Center Force

Task Force 34 would probably defeat the Center Force, especially in a radar-directed night interception, though Japanese torpedoes and limited American armor-piercing ammunition leave room for a painful fight.

Question

How would Task Force 34 fare against the Japanese Center Force at the Battle off Samar?

Short answer

It would probably win, most decisively in a radar-directed night action, but Japanese torpedoes could make the victory costly.

Notes

The proposed American battle line was powerful enough that the Japanese might withdraw rather than accept action. If Admiral Lee intercepted at night, American radar would create an advantage comparable to other battles in which radar-directed gunfire punished a less aware opponent. Yamato's radar and Japanese torpedoes still create danger, particularly if the Center Force secures a good torpedo approach. Task Force 34 also has finite armor-piercing ammunition, so the Americans would need to reserve it for battleships and use high explosive against cruisers once the major armored targets were engaged.