At the war's outset, too few escorts left merchant shipping exposed before German submarine numbers and tactics fully developed. A large prewar sloop force could blunt that numerical crisis and force submarines to confront organized protection earlier. It would not solve submarine warfare permanently because later stages still became a contest of sensors, weapons, and countermeasures. The earlier Type XXI example makes the distinction concrete: a later technological advance would demand a counter, but that future challenge did not excuse the avoidable early shortage of escort hulls. The failure came from avoiding a foreseeable problem whose threat and affordable response were already understood.
Notable Point · 47:43-49:12
Submarine war shifts from quantity to technology
More escorts would not eliminate submarines, but they could blunt the early numerical crisis and move the contest sooner toward detection and countermeasure technology.