Q&A · 1:33:31-1:38:16

How foreknowledge could redirect Royal Navy preparation

A counterfactual First Sea Lord plan prioritizes carriers, escorts, convoys, dual-purpose guns, and better destroyers over familiar mistakes.

Question

What would you change as the Sea Lords before the First and Second World Wars?

Short answer

Prioritize carrier construction, convoy defence, dual-purpose armament, escorts, and more capable destroyers rather than preserving flawed existing choices.

Notes

The proposed 1914 program removes Beatty, retains Agincourt, converts more ships to Renown-style battlecruisers, and begins carrier development earlier. It also expands escorts and motor torpedo boats while introducing convoys immediately to punish the still-small German submarine force. For the Second World War, the priorities are protected carrier production and rapid expansion of 4.5-inch dual-purpose mounts. Battle-class-style emergency destroyers and better-armed cruiser conversions would give the fleet more effective anti-aircraft and escort capacity from the outset.