Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 42:54-43:42

Royal Navy counterparts to Kamchatka's false alarms

British ships produced occasional false enemy reports, but drill made Kamchatka-style incidents unusual and merchant convoys posed a different coordination problem.

Convoy OperationsNaval DisciplineRoyal NavyWorld War IWorld War II
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Did the Royal Navy have a counterpart to Russia's Kamchatka?

Short answer

A few ships, including the First World War HMS Vanguard and some cruisers, produced false alarms, but British drill made such cases comparatively rare.

Notes

The First World War dreadnought HMS Vanguard is offered as an interesting Royal Navy counterpart to the Russian ship Kamchatka. Some cruisers also reported enemies they had only imagined. Such incidents remained relatively rare because British warships were generally well drilled and practised. Merchant crews brought into Second World War convoys faced a different learning curve as they adapted to disciplined group sailing.