Were British reservations about American escort-carrier designs justified, and did the Royal Navy use them unchanged?
Short answerThe reservations were justified for British needs, and the Royal Navy made substantial modifications to improve survivability.
NotesThe United States designed escort carriers as plentiful, replaceable platforms, following logic comparable to the Sherman tank. The Royal Navy wanted more resilience from ships that would operate in dangerous waters with limited replacement capacity. British yards therefore modified the transferred vessels rather than using them exactly as delivered. The resulting differences reflected national assumptions about production, damage, and the value of preserving each hull.