Q&A · 3:28:15-3:29:10

Roman quinqueremes with spar torpedoes

A spar torpedo fits a ramming culture better than most naval settings, but only by moving crews from an already dangerous collision to an uncertain explosive standoff.

Question

What if Roman quinqueremes invented the spar torpedo?

Short answer

It suits an existing willingness to ram, but developing a safe charge, spar length, and detonator would be extremely dangerous.

Notes

The counterfactual starts with Roman crews already willing to ram and risk their own vessel in close combat. A spar torpedo could increase the damage delivered before the hulls collide and might therefore appear tactically attractive. Its adoption would still demand dangerous experimentation to determine charge size, spar length, and a reliable contact mechanism. The speakers' humour underscores a serious point: early explosive weapons often transferred technical uncertainty directly onto the crews testing them.