Q&A ยท 1:41:16-1:41:50

Revising a narrative by studying neglected evidence

Revising a traditional model can result from a study of neglected evidence or a desire to reverse which side receives favorable treatment.

Question

Is ReOrient revisionist by definition because it revises the traditional model?

Short answer

In that literal sense, yes. The distinction is between revising a narrative to favor one side and conducting a proper study of neglected evidence.

Notes

The literal description of ReOrient as revisionist is accepted because it revises a traditional model. The distinction concerns the purpose and method of that revision. One approach changes a narrative principally to make a previously disfavored side look better. The approach credited to Frank begins with a subject that has not received a proper study and supplies that study.