Q&A · 2:58:31-2:59:14

Where Reginald Henderson might have commanded in wartime

A counterfactual places Reginald Henderson with either the Mediterranean Fleet or a Far Eastern command, the theaters he knew best.

Question

Which major fleet might Reginald Henderson have commanded during the Second World War?

Short answer

The Mediterranean Fleet or a Far Eastern command are the plausible choices, with the latter offering the more revealing test against Japan.

Notes

The proposed appointment is a reasoned counterfactual rather than a prediction. Reginald Henderson's experience makes the Mediterranean Fleet or a Far Eastern command the most plausible choices. He might have performed comparably to Andrew Cunningham in the Mediterranean. The Far East offers the more revealing test because it raises the question of how Henderson would have managed the Royal Navy's confrontation with Japan.