Are the Queen Elizabeth-class aircraft carriers a good design?
Short answerYes at the strategic level: STOVL aircraft allow carriers and LHDs to share aviation roles, giving a smaller fleet more usable flight decks.
NotesAlthough catapults offer advantages at the individual carrier level, STOVL aviation can be strategically sensible for a smaller navy. Two Queen Elizabeth-class carriers paired with three LHDs would provide five interoperable flight decks. An LHD would be a less capable strike carrier and a fleet carrier a less efficient amphibious ship, but either could cover a missing hull in an emergency. Common aircraft can create force-level resilience even when each deck is optimized for a different primary role.