Q&A · 1:22:11-1:23:31

Would Yamamoto have faced a postwar trial?

A trial for Pearl Harbor alone appears unlikely in this counterfactual because the commanders expected prior diplomatic warning, while other conduct raises separate questions.

Question

If Yamamoto had survived the war, would he have been put on trial?

Short answer

Probably not for Pearl Harbor alone, given the expectation of prior diplomatic warning, though separate crimes could have raised different questions.

Notes

Yamamoto was unlikely to face trial for Pearl Harbor alone in this counterfactual judgment. He and Nagumo expected the diplomats to deliver the warning before the strike. Possible responsibility for separate criminal actions would need its own examination. The comparison with Bomber Harris contributes to the doubt that prosecution would follow merely from directing the attack. Yamamoto might also have avoided capture through suicide, preventing a trial altogether.