Q&A: can theorists lack command experience?

Should practitioners take strategic theory seriously when its author has no practical command experience?

Yes. Historical study can produce valuable theory when the argument is rigorous enough to persuade both practitioners and political decision-makers.

Practical service is not a prerequisite for valuable strategic theory. Corbett lacked command experience, yet his historical arguments persuaded senior officers and politicians because they were rigorous and useful. Developing theory requires time to compare examples, context, and consequences, time that serving practitioners may not possess. The strongest test is whether the work explains problems convincingly and informs people responsible for decisions.