Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 18:31-19:28

What a battlecruiser would have added to Malta's Force K

A capital ship at Malta would have raised the threat Force K posed, though the counterfactual depends on a Royal Navy already stretched for heavy units.

BattlecruisersForce KHMS RenownMaltaMediterranean Theatre
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

How much stronger would Malta's Force K have been with Renown or another heavy-gun ship?

Short answer

Much stronger, because a battlecruiser or heavy cruiser would add decisive striking power, but the Royal Navy could not readily spare such a ship.

Notes

The counterfactual begins with the original Force K fighting Italy while Renown works with Warspite. Extending the idea to Malta, a battlecruiser or even an eight-inch-gun cruiser would have made the raiding force much more dangerous. The existing light force already achieved substantial results against Axis traffic. Ship shortages and competing demands kept such a major unit from being based there.