Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:52:11-2:52:42

Would a different FFG(X) bidder have solved the problem?

A viewer's objection about bidder selection receives an answer focused on the mismatch between the requirement and all available designs.

Constellation Class FrigatesMEKO A200Naval ProcurementParent DesignRiver Class DestroyersShip Design
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Would choosing a different FFG(X) bidder have avoided Constellation's problems?

Short answer

The reply rejects that explanation: none of the candidates is judged to meet the full requirement, and a new design is proposed instead.

Notes

MEKO is identified as closest to the brief, while the Canadian River-class Type 26 is identified as closer to the stated capabilities. Neither is judged to satisfy the whole requirement. The issue is framed as a mismatch between the Navy's desired ship and the available parent designs. The suggested clean-sheet alternative follows from that assessment.