Q&A ยท 1:12:30-1:13:22

Battlecruisers after a war that never comes

An alternate-history answer sees battlecruisers as an interim solution while navies learn how to make fast battleships work.

Question

Why assume that a world without World War I would still complete German battlecruisers and keep building the type?

Short answer

At least another battlecruiser generation would probably appear because fast battleships were not yet a fully solved technology; only then might they replace the type.

Notes

The Queen Elizabeth class shows designers trying to combine speed with battle-line power, but it did not reliably reach the hoped-for 25 knots. Without the First World War, at least one more generation of battlecruisers would probably appear while designers continued trying to make fast battleships work. Once a fast battleship achieves the necessary speed, it can absorb many battlecruiser tasks, but that transition is not yet complete in this scenario. The answer cautions against assuming that later ship categories would arrive on the same timetable after removing the war that accelerated their development.