Q&A · 2:47:01-2:54:35

Why interwar US-UK war plans do not prove a cold war

British and American plans against one another are interpreted as prudent worst-case exercises between the world's strongest navies rather than evidence of an active Anglo-American cold war.

Question

Was there an Anglo-American cold war between the world wars?

Short answer

No. Mutual war plans mainly represented sensible worst-case preparation by the world's two strongest navies, not an expectation of actual conflict.

Notes

Each navy had to test itself against the strongest plausible opponent, which naturally meant the other major English-speaking fleet. Planning and exercises built around that opponent exposed weaknesses that a weaker scenario would hide. Modern exercises likewise use friendly states as a capable red force without implying an intention to fight them. Political and technological competition existed, but there is little evidence that the two navies treated a real war as likely.