Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 1:38:40-1:42:54

Prometheus versus Odyssey as Starfleet's strongest ship

Prometheus divides into three fighting sections, while Odyssey combines a larger hull with later weapons and defences; the preferred answer changes with the era.

Fiction Odyssey ClassFiction Prometheus ClassFiction Sovereign ClassNebula Class Starships (Star Trek)Star TrekWarship Firepower
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Which Federation ship is strongest compared with Picard's Enterprise?

Short answer

Prometheus is one choice within Picard's Enterprise-command era; including later ships brings agreement on Odyssey, with its size and newer weapons and defences.

Notes

Prometheus can split into three warp-capable sections that attack together and force an opponent to divide its attention. Clarke favours it when thinking of the period in which Picard commanded the Enterprise, while another panelist chooses the later Odyssey. The case for Odyssey includes a hull over 1,000 metres long, multiple shielding layers and quantum-torpedo capability across its launchers. Improved phasers, tracking and weapon coverage strengthen that comparison. Clarke accepts Odyssey when the question includes the later era. A further objection to Prometheus is that concentrating weapons in one ship can sometimes work better than dividing the ship itself. The Nebula provides another comparison for the Next Generation era, with extra forward torpedo tubes and phasers relative to the Galaxy.