What if hypothetical fifteen-gun 9.2-inch cruisers in 1948 configuration replaced the American cruisers at Savo Island, with crews trained to use them?
Short answerTheir sensors, radar fire control, and trained crews make the battle extremely one-sided, provided commanders avoid serious tactical mistakes.
NotesThe scenario supplies hypothetical fifteen-gun 9.2-inch cruisers in 1948 configuration and crews trained for their equipment. Their firepower and sensors would make the encounter extremely one-sided if commanders avoided the historical mistakes. The Allied force already had considerable firepower, but poor preparation, leadership, communications, and understanding of radar undermined it. Des Moines and Worcester are later offered as comparisons for the advantage of trained crews using newer sensors. The crucial difference is detecting the threat, arranging the force, and making decisions quickly enough to use that firepower. The scenario explicitly modernizes only the cruisers, leaving the destroyers unchanged.