Porter blamed misfortune, the carronade battery, violated neutrality, inhumane conduct, and alleged plundering for the loss of Essex. Most of his personal property had been kept in the stern, which British fire had badly damaged. The neutrality accusation is challenged because Hillyar had earlier declined an invitation to attack inside the harbor. Hillyar praised Porter's conduct and reported that he surrendered after exhausting his alternatives. He also found provisions for a six-month cruise aboard Essex. The prisoners went to a Spanish prison hulk while repairs began on Phoebe and the captured frigate before the reinforcements arrived.
Notable Point · 2:08:29-2:12:02
Porter blamed dishonor while Hillyar praised his opponent
The rival post-battle narratives contrasted Porter's claims of misfortune and violated neutrality with Hillyar's generous report and practical repair work.