Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 34:35-35:11

Why Piorun did not fire torpedoes at Bismarck

Vian and Tovey defend Piorun's commander because holding the reserve station, rather than forcing a torpedo attack, fulfilled his assigned role.

Destroyer TacticsORP PiorunPhilip VianPolish Navy
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Was Piorun's commander investigated for not firing torpedoes?

Short answer

The issue was raised, but Vian and Tovey defended him because he had correctly performed Piorun's reserve role in the formation.

Notes

Some Polish authorities considered an inquiry into Commander Pławski for not launching torpedoes. Vian and Tovey rejected the criticism, and Vian's endorsement carried particular weight because of his own aggressive record. Piorun's assignment was to cover any lost corner in the formation. Holding that reserve station was tactical compliance rather than a lack of spirit.