Q&A ยท 3:08:11-3:08:36

How a Pearl Harbor landing would reach shore

A counterfactual compares disguised merchant ships with dedicated landing craft for an assault synchronised with the opening air strikes.

Question

Could Japan have landed troops at Pearl Harbor from merchant ships disguised as neutral vessels?

Short answer

It could have tried, but dedicated landing craft offered a better chance of putting troops ashore quickly during a dawn assault coordinated with the air strikes.

Notes

Merchant ships disguised as neutral vessels were a poor substitute for landing craft and assault shipping able to put troops ashore quickly. The proposed attack would begin around dawn while defenders were already responding to the air strikes. This operational extension of the counterfactual required destruction of the base and its organisation as well as damage to battleships.