Were Neosho-type US fleet oilers unsuitable for Atlantic operations?
Short answerNo; they were adequate for their supply role, which did not require high-speed manoeuvring in major storms.
NotesNeosho-type fleet oilers are judged adequate for Atlantic operations. Their task is to keep carrying supplies and supporting the fleet. High-speed manoeuvring through severe storms is not the standard used to assess them. The oiler's job differs from that of a fast combatant.