Q&A ยท 1:19:31-1:21:56

What limited severe punishment aboard Royal Navy ships?

Medical authority, manpower value, danger to the ship, and the crew's numerical strength all constrained severe punishment.

Question

What limited severe corporal punishment aboard a Royal Navy ship?

Short answer

Captains could commute unserved lashes, surgeons could stop a punishment, and trained sailors were too valuable to waste; officers also depended on much larger crews.

Notes

Shipboard punishment was intended to restore discipline while retaining a sailor's service. A captain could commute the unserved portion of a sentence, and a surgeon could stop a flogging when continuing became medically unsafe. Keel-hauling was a poor practical choice because it could kill the sailor and damage the hull or rudder. Officers also depended on the cooperation of crews who greatly outnumbered them, placing another practical limit on arbitrary punishment.