N-class versus Fletcher in a destroyer gunfight

How would an N-class destroyer fare against a Fletcher-class destroyer?

The N class may have a slight gunfight edge, but Fletcher's larger torpedo battery remains a major threat.

The comparison pits six 4.7-inch guns against five 5-inch guns and notes the Fletcher's ten torpedoes. The N class receives a slight edge in a gun action because cumulative shell hits matter greatly against unarmoured destroyers. Fletcher's larger torpedo battery remains a serious advantage, and one hit could decide the action. The outcome therefore turns on whether the engagement develops as a gunfight or gives the American ship an effective torpedo opportunity.