How would HMS Tiger and a sister ship fare against a Scharnhorst armed with four triple 11-inch turrets?
Short answerIf modernized to about 30-33 knots with radar-directed 14-inch guns, the two Tigers would control the range and overwhelm Scharnhorst's twelve 11-inch guns.
NotesTwo Tigers would bring sixteen 14-inch guns against Scharnhorst's twelve smaller weapons. A comprehensive modernization gives them enough speed to choose the engagement distance and radar direction to exploit their battery. The pair would probably penetrate and defeat the German ship despite its heavier numerical broadside count.