Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 3:30:11-3:30:43

Radar-guided US cruisers make Jutland one-sided

Replacing Britain's battlecruisers with later American cruisers and destroyers gives the Grand Fleet radar-directed firepower from a later technological era.

Alaska Class Large CruisersAlternate HistoryBattle Of JutlandDes Moines Class Heavy CruisersGearing Class DestroyersHigh Seas FleetRadar Directed Gunnery
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

How would two Alaska-class and two Des Moines-class cruisers with four Gearing-class destroyers fare if they replaced Britain's battlecruisers at Jutland?

Short answer

Their radar-guided gunnery makes the encounter overwhelmingly one-sided against the High Seas Fleet.

Notes

Radar-guided gunnery decides the result without requiring a detailed replay of the historical deployment. The substituted force consists of two Alaska-class cruisers, two Des Moines-class cruisers, and four Gearing-class destroyers from a later technological era. The High Seas Fleet cannot match their fire control, making the engagement decisively one-sided. Warspite and the other Queen Elizabeth-class ships would gain unusually capable partners rather than face a balanced counterfactual.