Q&A · 5:06:12-5:08:41

Classifying a proposed Anglo-American 8-inch command cruiser

A proposed Anglo-American nine-gun ship prompts disagreement over its purpose, with command-cruiser classification, railguns, and national status all considered.

Question

How would a jointly developed British and American ship with nine 8-inch guns be classified?

Short answer

A command cruiser, potentially a nuclear guided-missile cruiser (CGN); the value of its conventional gun battery remains disputed.

Notes

A jointly developed British and American ship with nine 8-inch guns is classified here as a command cruiser, potentially a CGN if nuclear powered. One objection is that the conventional gun battery gives the project little reason to exist; the response suggests a working railgun and the status attached to a large capital ship. An alternate-timeline Red Fleet illustration takes the idea further with four large guns subordinate to missiles and helicopters. Its vertical-launch cells are placed beside the radar in the design being shown. The exchange leaves the practicality disputed and distinguishes the imagined design from an established naval programme.