Q&A · 2:46:46-2:47:32

Could navies again face a convoy-escort shortage?

A live force-structure question connects today's limited escort numbers to Cold War assumptions that a major war would go nuclear before long convoy campaigns mattered.

Question

Could navies again have to choose between protecting the battle fleet and the merchant fleet with too few destroyers?

Short answer

Yes; modern escort numbers reflect short-war and nuclear assumptions, so a prolonged conventional convoy campaign could expose a serious force-structure gap.

Notes

Modern fleets have far fewer escorts relative to the merchant traffic they might need to protect. Part of that structure came from an assumption that a major war would become nuclear before a long convoy campaign developed. A prolonged conventional conflict would force navies to divide scarce destroyers and frigates between battle groups and trade protection. One remedy would be to buy many more escorts across several classes.