Q&A · 3:44:40-3:45:11

Did Lindemann say he would not have his ship shot out from under him?

Lindemann's frustration is plausible, but the famous wording cannot be confirmed.

Question

Did Captain Lindemann actually say, 'I will not have my ship shot out from under me'?

Short answer

Possibly, and he does appear to have been angry, but the exact phrase cannot be treated as certain.

Notes

Lindemann appears to have been annoyed by the delay in returning fire. The familiar quotation is possible, but its exact wording is doubtful. His frustration can be distinguished from certainty about the words he used. The phrase is the version that survived in later accounts.