Q&A · 1:06:26-1:08:14

Why larger guns are not a simple battleship refit

Their barbettes may offer theoretical room, but new turrets, uneven barbette dimensions, cost, maintenance, and lost guns make the conversion unattractive.

Question

Could the Wyoming or Rivadavia classes have been refitted with 14-inch guns?

Short answer

Their barbettes may offer theoretical room, but new turrets, uneven barbette dimensions, cost, maintenance, and lost guns make the conversion unattractive.

Notes

A physically possible refit may still be a poor modernization. Installing a larger weapon would require a completely new turret fitted into the existing barbette. The assessment rests on a recollection that the Rivadavia and Wyoming barbettes could accommodate 14-inch guns, with a qualification that some Wyoming superfiring positions were narrower. Those positions might force a reduction in the number of guns. Even where the machinery can be made to fit, the resulting ship could be expensive, difficult to maintain, and less useful than a cleaner design solution.